The Indiana Pacers and New York Knicks have waged some of the most memorable battles in NBA playoff history. These two teams have met eight times in the postseason. The Knicks winning in 1993, 1994, 1999. Indiana with wins in 1995, 1998, 2000, 2013, and 2024. Games and players that will be remembered forever. Hall of Famers such as Reggie Miller, Patrick Ewing, Mark Jackson, Chris Mullin and Carmelo Anthony. Excellent role players who complimented their teams and made each squad a complete unit on the court. Those players included names such as Dale Davis, John Starks, Jalen Rose, Greg Anthony, Rik Smits, Derek Harper, Derrick McKey, Allen Houston, Antonio Davis, Charles Oakley, Byron Scott and Latrell Sprewell. Head coaches who roamed the sidelines like Pat Riley, Larry Bird, Larry Brown and Jeff Van Gundy. Players, coaches and so many memories. This rivalry had it all. Now in 2025, these two franchises meet again in the Eastern Conference Finals. Four wins away from the NBA Finals.
Let’s take a look back at some of the most memorable moments in this rivalry.
This rivalry began in the first round of the 1993 playoffs. The Pacers were the number 8 seed facing off against the number 1 seed Knicks. The Pacers came into this series a very young squad and the heavily favored Knicks dispatched of them in four games, winning the series 3-1. This series is most known for the incident that took place at Market Square Arena in game three. This is when the rivalry was born. The Pacers were down 2-0 in the series and needed a win to keep their season alive. Pacers sharpshooter Reggie Miller who was known for his trash talking decided to get in the head of Knicks guard John Starks.
Miller would antagonize Starks all game and with the Pacers up big late in the contest, Starks would hit his breaking point. As both players ran down the floor, Miller would nudge Starks and then while confronting the Pacers guard, John Starks would proceed to headbutt him. The incident would see Starks ejected from the game much to the delight of Miller and the Indiana crowd. The Pacers would win the game but ultimately fall in four games. The Knicks would advance to the Eastern Conference Finals where they would fall to the eventual champion Chicago Bulls. This however set the stage for what was to become one of the most storied rivalries in NBA History.
The following year in the 1994 Eastern Conference Finals the Pacers and Knicks series would become the rivalry that the rest of the NBA would be talking about for the foreseeable future.
The Pacers came into the 1994 Eastern Conference Finals in unprecedented territory. They dispatched of Shaquille O'Neal and the Orlando Magic in the first round by sweeping them. This marked the first time in their NBA history that the Pacers would win a playoff series. They next defeated the top seeded Atlanta Hawks in six games. This would bring the basketball crazy state of Indiana to a boiling point. Nobody thought the Indiana Pacers would be playing for a chance at the NBA Finals. The Knicks were waiting. Things were about to get very interesting.
After The Knicks won the first two games in New York, the Pacers would return the favor and take the next two games in Indianapolis. Up next was game five back at Madison Square Garden in New York. This game was known for the players on the court and a certain fan sitting in the front row. Enter the Reggie Miller vs Spike Lee saga.
For much of game 5 of the 1994 Eastern Conference Finals, the Knicks were in firm control of the game. The Knicks held a 70-58 lead going into the fourth quarter. Things seemed bleak for the Pacers and Reggie Miller was playing poorly. Miller was also hearing it from the Knicks biggest fan, movie director Spike Lee who had a front row seat. The last quarter will go down as one of the most astonishing shooting displays in playoff history. Reggie Miller caught fire. He scored 25 points in the fourth quarter. Every bucket Miller scored, he would proceed to stare at Spike Lee. At one point Miller would give Spike Lee the choke sign. Miller's antics along with his shooting propelled the Pacers to a comeback victory 93-86 and a 3-2 lead in the series. The Pacers were one win away from The NBA Finals.
Back in Indianapolis for game six, the state of Indiana was at a fever pitch. The whole state was a buzz. The Indiana faithful would come out in force in support of their beloved Pacers and to show their distain for the Knicks and Spike Lee. Indiana was ready to move onto the NBA Finals and face the Houston Rockets. This however was not meant to be. With Spike Lee courtside at Market Square Arena, the Knicks would shock the Pacers on their home floor and win game six by a score of 98-91. John Starks led the Knicks with 26 points. It was back to New York for the decisive game seven.
Game seven was another close battle throughout but the Knicks would prevail 94-90 behind the heroics of their superstar center Patrick Ewing. His put back dunk with under a minute left would be the nail in the Pacers coffin. The Knicks advanced to their first appearance in the NBA Finals since 1973. The Pacers had nothing to be ashamed of. They put themselves on the NBA map and let the rest of the league take notice that they would be around for a long time. The Knicks would come close but end up falling in seven games to the Houston Rockets in the Finals. The Pacers and Knicks rivalry was just heating up.
The Pacers and Knicks would meet for the third year in a row during the playoffs in 1995. This time would be in the Eastern Conference Semi Finals. The Pacers would defeat the Atlanta Hawks in a sweep in the first round. New York would defeat the Cleveland Cavaliers in their first round matchup in five games. The Pacers and Knicks were set to meet for a chance to advance to the Conference Finals. This series had some intriguing headlines. Mark Jackson, who played for the Knicks from 1987-1992 and was born in New York was now a member of the Indiana Pacers. He wanted revenge on his former team for letting him go.
Game one of the 1995 series was one that fans of either team will ever forget. The stage was set in New York. With the Pacers down 105-99 with 18.7 seconds left, it seemed over. Most fans had started heading for the exits. Then the unthinkable. Reggie Miller hit a three pointer to cut the Knicks lead to 105-102. Miller would then steal the inbound pass and race back to the three point line where he buried another to tie the game at 105. Madison Square Garden was in shock. Stunned silence. Miller would then be fouled after John Starks missed two potential game winning free throws. Reggie would make his two free throws to put the Pacers up 107-105 with seven seconds left. The Pacers would go onto win the game. This comeback would be remembered as eight points in eight point nine seconds. Reggie Miller officially cemented himself as New York's biggest nightmare.
The series would go back and forth. New York winning game two, the Pacers winning games three and four at Market Square Arena. The Pacers looked to knock out the Knicks from the playoffs but New York wouldn't go down without a fight. The Knicks fought back to win games five and six to set up another decisive game seven at Madison Square Garden in New York City. This game would decide who would go onto the Eastern Conference Finals and face the Orlando Magic.
Game 7 would be an instant classic. Indiana had a big lead but New York fought back to close the gap late in the game. With the Pacers leading 97-95 with just seconds left, New York had the basketball. Patrick Ewing drove to the basket and had a wide open layup with a chance to send the game into overtime. The ball bounced off the back of the rim and fell off. Game over. The Pacers had finally beaten the Knicks in a playoff series. Though they would fall to Orlando in the Eastern Conference Finals in seven games, the Pacers knew they were a contender for the NBA Championship. They had the belief.
The rivalry in the playoffs would lay dormant for the next few seasons but would pick right back up in 1998. The Pacers and Knicks would meet in the Eastern Conference Semi Finals. This series was much more exciting for Indiana than it was for New York. The Pacers would take care of the Knicks in five games. The memorable moment from this series took place in game four. Reggie Miller would stick a dagger in New York City once again in Madison Square Garden. His three pointer to tie the game in the final seconds would send it to overtime where the Pacers would go onto win 118-107. Indiana would wrap up the series in the next game at home to advance to the Eastern Conference Finals where they would fall to Michael Jordan and the Bulls in seven games.
1999 was another series to remember. The Pacers looked like they were on their way to the NBA Finals. The Knicks came into the playoffs as the number eight seed. No eight seed had ever made the NBA Finals. The Pacers had defeated Cleveland and Philadelphia in their first two playoff series. New York upset the Miami Heat and Atlanta Hawks to make an improbable run to the Eastern Conference Finals. The Pacers were the favorites coming into the matchup with their arch rivals.
The Pacers had the home court advantage but the Knicks took game one in Indianapolis 93-90. Indiana bounced back in game two 88-86 and the stage was headed back to New York. Game three was memorable for its ending. Down by three with seconds left, Knicks forward Larry Johnson took a three pointer from the wing. Pacers forward Antonio Davis fouled Johnson on the shot. Johnson made the three pointer. Madison Square Garden was in a frenzy. He would then make the free throw to win the game for New York 92-91. The Knicks took a 2-1 series lead. Indiana never recovered as New York would win the series in six games. They became the first team in NBA history to advance to the NBA Finals as the eight seed. The Knicks would fall to the San Antonio Spurs in the Finals in six games.
In 2000 once again the Pacers and Knicks met in the Eastern Conference Finals. Indiana was desperate to finally get over the hump and advance to the NBA Finals. The Pacers came into the series as the Eastern Conference's top seed. They had the home court advantage in their brand new arena, Conseco Fieldhouse. This would finally be the year Indiana would make the climb. The Pacers would win the first two games in Indianapolis, the Knicks followed up with two wins in New York. Indiana would win game five at home. Back to New York for game six. This was the game that Indiana and its fans had waited for.
Game six in New York was a game where Reggie Miller took over and finally led his team to the NBA Finals. His 33 points would help the Pacers beat the Knicks 93-80 and for the first time in their history, the Indiana Pacers were headed to the NBA Finals. Indiana was on cloud nine. After years of trying and several failed attempts in the Conference Finals against their arch rivals, the Pacers finally conquered the demons in their own backyard.
The Pacers and Knicks playoff rivalry would fade away for the next 13 years. Both franchises would see their future Hall of Fame players retire. The teams would have their share of struggles in the mid-late 2000s into the 2010s. In 2013 the playoff rivalry that had been dormant for over a decade finally resurfaced in the second round. New players such as Paul George and Carmelo Anthony. New coaches like Frank Vogel and former IU standout Mike Woodson. However, the same memories remained for both fanbases. The anticipation was as eagerly exciting as it was in the 1990s. The Pacers would have the final word as they defeated the Knicks in six games to advance to the Eastern Conference Finals where they would fall to eventual champion Miami. The defining moment in this series was in game six when Pacers center Roy Hibbert blocked Knicks forward Carmelo Anthony on a dunk attempt to help the Pacers to a victory.
Once again the rivalry lay quiet for the next decade when a new era emerged to bring back the nostalgia of playoff basketball between New York and Indiana in 2024. This time around it was players like Tyrese Haliburton and Myles Turner for the Pacers and Jalen Brunson and Josh Hart for the Knicks. The teams would square off in the second round. Indiana would once again take the hearts of the New York and win an epic series in seven games, culminating in a game seven triumph in Madison Square Garden 130-109. The Pacers set an NBA playoff record in game seven by shooting 67 percent from the floor.
So here we are once again in 2025. The Eastern Conference Finals. Indiana vs New York. Winner advances to the NBA Finals. This is the first time in 25 years these teams will have met in the Conference Finals. This rivalry stretches generations. The moments and memories will be talked about for years to come. It just wouldn't be the NBA playoffs without the Pacers and the Knicks rivalry.